Domestic Preparedness for Trade in Services Liberalization: Are East African Countries prepared for Further Trade Liberalization?

Elias Peter Bagumhe

Abstract


Services are the fastest growing sectors in the global economy. Over the past decades East African countries have witnessed even faster growing rates of the share of trade services in their GDPs. The total services export of EAC countries increased from USD 1868 mills in 1995 to USD 5681 mills in 2008 (WDI 2010) which is approximately three times increase compared to 1995. Along with this growth, liberalization of services trade is becoming a critical economic agenda of these economies. EAC countries have also made unilateral liberalizations in a number of services sectors since the mid 1980’s. On top of that EAC countries have also made commitment to liberalize service trade at the multilateral level. Furthermore a significant commitment of their services sectors has been made under the East African Integration Process beginning from first July 2010. This paper argues that although the importance of services as a share of overall GDP, increase with growth on FDI and employment. Its growth can be driven by number of factors, such as final demand factors and basic structural changes in production, linked to development. Weak domestic preparedness before opening up is likely to be associated with unsatisfactory and undesirable outcomes of services trade liberalization. This paper tries to expound issues that are essential on domestic preparedness for service trade liberalization and analyses the associated concerns. The purpose of this paper is not to provide answers but to shed some light on how services Trade liberalization is currently operationalized in the East African countries, in particular, that is, to open up the “black box”, and indicate the operational design elements around which variance is the highest.


CITE AS:
Bagumhe, E. P. (2012). Preparación doméstica para la liberalización del comercio de servicios. ¿Están los países africanos preparados para una mayor liberalización comercial?. Iberoamerican Journal of Development Studies, 1 (2): 28-51

References


AMITI M, WEI SJ (2005). Fear of Services Outsourcing: is it Justified? Economic Policy 20(42):308-347

ARNOD JM, JAVORCIK B, MATTOO A (2007). The Productivity effects of Services Liberalization: Evidence from the Czech Republic. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 4109

BANK OF TANZANIA (BoT) AND TANZANIA INVESTMENT CENTRE (TIC) (2006). Tanzania Investment Report

BLYDE J, SINYAVSKAYA N (2007). The Impact of Liberalizing Trade in Services on Trade in Goods: An Empirical Investigation. Review of Development Economics 11(3):566-583

CHANDA R (2008). Services Trade and Investment Liberalisation, and Domestic Regulation: A Summary of Six Country Studies. CUTS, Jaipur

COMTRADE (2010). United Nations Commodity Trade Statistics Database. United Nations Statistics Division

CUTS INTERNATIONAL, TRADE IN SERVICES & DEVELOPING COUNTRIES (2005). The Market Access Barriers, Policy Brief http://www.cuts-citee.org/PDF/PB2-2005.pdf ., February 2005

DAWN (2005). Pakistan submits initial offers list to WTO: Opens all major sectors to FSPs. 31-5-2005

DE MEL D, WIJAYASIRI J (2008). Domestic Preparedness of Sri Lanka with respect to Services Trade Liberalisation: Case Study of the Telecom Sector. Paper Prepared as part of the WTO Doha Round & South Asia: Linking Civil Society with Trade Negotiations, Phase 2 Project, CUTS, Jaipur

EAC (2009a). East African Community Facts & Figures. EAC Secretariat Report, Arusha

EAC (2009b). Protocol on the Establishment of the East African Common Market by East African Community Secretariat

EL-ETREBY R (2008). Globalization of Services Trade and the Establishment of Industry Coalitions. ITC World Trade Net Business Briefing (14 April)

FEKETEKUTY G (2008). A Guide to Services Negotiations, Appendix A. In: Mattoo A, Stern RM and Zanini G (eds.). A Handbook of International Trade in Services. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 542-592

FRANCOIS, J, WOERZ J (2008). Producer Services, Manufacturing Linkages, and Trade. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade 8(3):199-229

FRANCOIS J, VAN MEIJL H, VAN TONGEREN F (2003). Economic Benefits of the Doha Round for the Netherlands. Agricultural Economics Institute, The Hague

GOOTIZ B, MATTOO A (2009). Services in Doha. What’s on the Table? The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 4903. Washington DC

HODGE J (2002). Liberalization of Trade in Services in Developing Countries, Development,Trade, and the WTO. The World Bank

HOEKMAN B (2002). Strengthening the global trade architecture for development. Policy Research Working Paper Series 2757, The World Bank

HOEKMAN B (2006). Liberalizing Trade in Services: a Survey. Policy Research Working Paper 4030. The World Bank, Washington DC

HOEKMAN B, MATTOO A (2007). Regulatory cooperation, aid for trade and the general agreement on trade in services. Policy Research Working Paper Series 4451, The World Bank

HOEKMAN B, MATTOO A (2008). Services Trade and Growth. Policy Research Working Paper 4461. The World Bank, Washington DC

HOEKMAN B, MATTOO A, SAPIR A (2007). The political economy of services trade liberalization: a case for international regulatory cooperation? Oxford Review of Economic Policy 23(3):367-391

HUFBAUER GC, WARREN T (1999). The Globalization of Services: What Has Happened? What are the Implications. Institute for International Economics, Australian National University. http://www.iie.com/publications/wp/1999/99-12.pdf

INTERNATIONAL TRADE CENTRE UNCTAD/WTO AND THE COMMONWEALTH SECRETARIAT (2002). Business Guide to the General Agreement on Trade in Services. ITC, Geneva

JUAN B, SINYANVSKAYA N (2007). The Impact of Liberalizing Trade in Services on Trade in Goods: An Empirical Investigation. Review of Development Economics 11(3):536-583

KARSENTY G (2003). The GATS Agreement and the four modes of supply – A new ground for Statisticians. World Trade Organization

KUMAR P (2005). Services Negotiations in Doha Round: Concerns of South Asia. CUTS, Jaipur

KUMAR P, JATKAR A (2008). Domestic Preparedness of India in Trade in Services. Paper prepared as part of the WTO Doha Round & South Asia: Linking Civil Society with Trade Negotiations Phase 2 Project, CUTS, Jaipur. Liberalization. Working Paper No 97/55, International Monetary Fund

MAJID, N (2003). Globalization and Poverty, Employment Paper 2003/54, ILO, Geneva

MATTOO A (2006). Services in a Development Round: Proposals for overcoming inertial. Washington DC

MATTOO A, SAUVÉ P, (2003). Domestic Regulation and Services Trade Liberalization. Oxford University Press, Washington DC

MATTOO A, SAUVÉ P, (2010). The Preferential Liberalization of Services Trade. NCCR Working Paper No 2010/13 (May). World Trade Institute, Bern

MATTOO A, SUBRAMANIAN A (2011). China and the world trading system. Policy Research Working Paper Series 5897, The World Bank

MBEKEANI KK (2003). GATS Negotiations Must Focus on Services Liberalization: The Case of SADC. Development Outreach, World Bank Publication, July 2003

OECD (2000). Towards Sustainable Development. Indicators to Measure Progress. Rome Conference. OECD, Paris

OECD (2002). Managing the Request – Offer Negotiation the GATS, TD/TC/WP/2002 (13) Final. OECD, Paris (21 June)

OECD (2003). Opening up Trade in Services: Opportunities and Gains for Developing Countries, Policy Brief. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris (August)

OECD (2008). OECD Handbook on Economic Globalisation Indicators. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development

ONYANGO CH (2007). Negotiations of Distribution Services in the WTO: An Analysis of the US and EU Requests to Kenya. Paper presented during National Workshop on Trade in Services organized by the Ministry of Trade and Industry in association with the International Lawyers and Economists Against Poverty (ILEAP). 26th-27th March 2007. Nairobi, Kenya

PARACHA MA (2008). Domestic Preparedness’ with respect to Services Trade Liberalization in Pakistan. Paper prepared as part of the WTO Doha Round & South Asia: Linking Civil Society with Trade Negotiations Phase 2 Project. CUTS, Jaipur

RAIHAN S, AHMED M (2008). Domestic Preparedness for Services Trade Liberalization in Bangladesh. Paper prepared as part of the WTO Doha Round & South Asia: Linking Civil Society with Trade Negotiations Phase 2 Project. CUTS, Jaipur

ROY M, MARCHETTI J, LIM H (2007). Services Liberalization in the New Generation of Preferential Trade Agreements (PTAs): How much further than the GATS? World Trade Review 6(2):155-192

SAUVÉ P (2002). Completing the GATS Framework: Safeguards, Subsidies, and Government Procurement. In: Hoekman B, Mattoo A and English P (eds.). Development, Trade and the WTO: A Handbook. The World Bank, Washington DC, pp 326-335

SAUVÉ P (2008). Conducting a Trade-Related Regulatory Audit in Financial Services. Mimeo. The World Bank, Washington DC

SAUVÉ P, WARD N (2008). The EU-CARIFO-RUM Economic Partnership Agreement: Assessing the Progress on Services and Investment. NCCR Working Paper No. 2008/10. World Trade Institute, Bern (May)

SAUVÉ P, WARD N (2009). The EC-CARIFORUM Economic Partnership Agreement: assessing the outcome on services and investment. European Centre for International Political Economy, Brussels, January

SAWTEE (2008). Nepal’s Preparedness with Respect to Select Services Sector Liberalisation. Paper prepared as part of the WTO Doha Round & South Asia: Linking Civil Society with Trade Negotiations Phase 2 Project. CUTS, Jaipur

SOBHAN R (2004). Road map of South Asian Cooperation. Paper read at South Asian Free Media Association’s (SAFMA) Conference on Regional Cooperation on August 20-21, 2004, at Dhaka, Bangladesh

SORSA P (1997). The GATS agreement on Financial Services: A Modest Start to Multilateral. Study on the Impact of the Implementation of the East African Customs Union on the Business Community – 2008 by Economic Research Bureau/TCCIA. University of Dar es Salaam

TRALAC (2011). Managing the Process of Services Liberalisation. Trade Law Centre for Southern Africa (TRALAC)

UNCTAD (1998). Liberalizing Trade in Services: A Handbook. Geneva, Switzerland

UNCTAD (2006). Developing productive capacities: the least developed countries report 2006, UNCTAD, Geneva

UNCTAD (2011). Handbook of Statistics. Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development

VONKHORPORN P (2008). Preparing for FTA negotiations, Thailand’s Experience presentation to the ADB course in trade in Service

WANGWE S (2003). African Systems of Innovation: Towards an Interpretation of the Development Experience. Revised version of paper presented at the International Workshop on African Systems of Innovation and Competence-building in the Era of Globalization, Denmark: University of Aalborg, March, 2001

WDI (2010). World Development Indicators. World Bank, Washington DC

WDI (2011). World Investment Report. UNCTAD

WORLD BANK (2009). World Development Indicators. 2009. Washington DC

WORLD BANK (2010). Reform and regional integration of professional services in East Africa: time for action, World Bank, Washington DC

WORLD BANK (2011). World Development Indicators, Part 2. The World Bank: Data [online]. Available from: http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/world-development-indicators .

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION, Council for Trade in Services – Special Session, Conditional Initial Offers on Services of Pakistan, TN/S/O/PAK, 30 May 2005

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION, Economic Research and Statistics Division, Measuringtrade in services, training module produced for the World Bank, November 2003

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION, GATS – Fact and Fiction, WTO Secretariat, Geneva

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION, GATS Schedule of Specific Commitment, WTO Secretariat, Geneva

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION, Trade Policy Course, GATS – Services, WTO Secretariat, Geneva

WTO (2009). World Trade Report 2009. WTO Secretariat, Geneva

WTO (2010). World Trade Organization. Annual Report. Geneva, Switzerland

WTO Wing, Ministry of Commerce, Government of Pakistan, Finalization of offers by Pakistan under GATS negotiations in the WTO. Working Paper, 2004




DOI: https://doi.org/10.26754/ojs_ried/ijds.63

Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.